Western Brands Are Losing More Ground to Cheaper Chinese Rivals

In recent months, the shift in consumer behavior in China has significantly impacted major Western brands such as L’Oréal and LVMH, causing them to report disappointing earnings where local competitors thrive. The growing consumer frugality in China, driven by a combination of economic challenges and changing tastes, has allowed affordable local brands to flourish, further intensifying the competitive landscape for international companies.

The stark contrast between the performance of L’Oréal and Proya Cosmetics illustrates this shift. Recently, L’Oréal SA announced a 6.5% drop in like-for-like sales in North Asia, including China, attributed to a pessimistic consumer sentiment. Meanwhile, Proya Cosmetics, based in Hangzhou, reported a remarkable 21% jump in sales and profit during the same quarter. This divergence underscores how local brands, adept at leveraging e-commerce and maintaining competitive prices, are rapidly gaining market share at the expense of their more expensive rivals.

Ernan Cui, a consumer analyst at Gavekal Dragonomics, pointed out that “local brands are winning,” stating how consumers have become increasingly sensitive to pricing and value in a landscape marked by weak economic growth. This trend is evident even beyond the cosmetics sector. Luxury giant LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton recently faced its worst quarter since the onset of the pandemic, while Starbucks has been steadily losing customers to cheaper local alternatives like Luckin Coffee, which offers Americano for as low as $1.40.

Moreover, iconic brands such as Nike and Uniqlo have also experienced declining sales, reinforcing the idea that many consumers are gravitating towards more affordable options, or “pingti,” as it is referred to in Mandarin. In response to this downshift in consumption, brands need to rethink their strategies. The distinct consumer preference for value-driven products is reshaping the retail landscape in China, compelling brands to reconsider their pricing tactics and marketing approaches to reconnect with the market.

One notable success story in this frugal climate is the Chinese budget retailer Miniso, which is projected to achieve yet another quarter of double-digit sales growth. Analysts predict that Luckin Coffee’s revenue growth in the third quarter remains solid at over 30%, illustrating strong consumer demand for affordable coffee options. This trend is not isolated to a few standout brands; several local cosmetics labels, such as Kans and Comfy, are outpacing global giants like Estée Lauder, which has reported a staggering 35% to 50% sales decline within the past year on dominant e-commerce platforms like Alibaba.

Data from Hangzhou Zhiyi Tech reveals these troubling figures for Western brands: L’Oréal, Estée Lauder, Procter & Gamble’s SK-II, and Shiseido have all faced declines in sales of this magnitude over the twelve-month period leading up to September. In stark contrast, Proya and other local labels have reported over 20% growth during the same timeframe, highlighting the appetite for domestic products among Chinese consumers.

Citigroup analysts recently commented on L’Oréal’s decline as indicative of “challenging demand particularly in the off season and increasing competition from domestic brands,” emphasizing that premium offerings are particularly vulnerable to shifts in consumer spending patterns. There appears to be no silver lining on the horizon, even during major holidays, which historically boost luxury consumption.

As this trend unfolds, what can Western brands learn from their domestic competitors? There is a clear demand for innovative, affordable products prominently marketed through digital platforms, which local brands exploit effectively. An agile marketing strategy that emphasizes value and community engagement might be key for Western brands seeking to regain lost ground in this fiercely competitive market.

In conclusion, as Chinese consumers navigate their economic circumstances and prioritize value, Western brands must adapt to a new era of brand loyalty driven by affordability and accessibility. The success of local brands in this landscape reveals not only changing consumer preferences but a growing opportunity for Western companies to rethink their global strategies in response.

Back To Top